A Universal Basic Income for Aotearoa NZ?

A Universal Basic Income (UBI) is an unconditional minimum income provided to every member of society regardless of age, working status or level of income. The UBI seeks to maintain a functional market economy in the face of increasing technological disruption, unemployment, wealth inequality, and a hollowing out of the middle class. It would provide every citizen with enough income to cover the costs of their basic needs. Bettering one’s situation beyond this foundational amount is then the responsibility of each individual as usual. Most UBI proposals involve suggestions of significant reform of the welfare such as removing means testing and abatement of payments and many even include substantial overhaul of taxation systems.

A Universal Basic Income (UBI) is an unconditional minimum income provided to every member of society regardless of age, working status or level of income. The UBI seeks to maintain a functional market economy in the face of increasing technological disruption, unemployment, wealth inequality, and a hollowing out of the middle class. It would provide every citizen with enough income to cover the costs of their basic needs. Bettering one’s situation beyond this foundational amount is then the responsibility of each individual as usual. Most UBI proposals involve suggestions of significant reform of the welfare such as removing means testing and abatement of payments and many even include substantial overhaul of taxation systems.

Surely we can do no worse by fundamentally reconsidering the broken system that fails to meet the needs of so many to meet their families’ basic needs. Proponents believe that a Universal Basic Income might go a long way to achieving just that and has potential to be a significant game changing policy for the economic and social fabric of our nation. UBI is certainly no panacea and will need to be part of a comprehensive look at how we structure our society for a resilient future, however it certainly is one of the most promising proposals being seriously considered by establishment politics at this stage.

Comment to consider and vote on:
“NZ needs a new system that better guarantees the welfare of the least well off and those facing insecure work conditions.”

Original Polis poll: https://pol.is/4yy3sh84js Soop article: https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/HL1709/S00031/hivemind-report-a-universal-basic-income-for-aotearoa-nz.htm

Summary of the Comment Section

This section showcases different methods for selecting representative comments from a broader discussion (see the comment section below). For each method, the goal is to highlight a small set of comments that best reflect the conversation. They each approach this task from a different standpoint, emphasising different principles, such as popularity, representation or diversity (among others).

Show Advanced Controls

Popularity-Based Selection

Approval Voting
Chamberlin–Courant
Consensus Rule
Method of Equal Shares
Method of Equal Shares with Approval Voting Completion
Method of Equal Shares with Increment Completion
Proportional Approval Voting
Eneström–Phragmén
Satisfaction Approval Voting
Sequential Proportional Approval Voting
Phragmén's Sequential Rule
Popularity
max. popularity:
Inclusion
max. inclusion:
Satisfaction Distribution

Representation-Based Selection

Approval Voting
Chamberlin–Courant
Consensus Rule
Method of Equal Shares
Method of Equal Shares with Approval Voting Completion
Method of Equal Shares with Increment Completion
Proportional Approval Voting
Eneström–Phragmén
Satisfaction Approval Voting
Sequential Proportional Approval Voting
Phragmén's Sequential Rule
Popularity
max. popularity:
Inclusion
max. inclusion:
Satisfaction Distribution

Diversity-Based Selection

Approval Voting
Chamberlin–Courant
Consensus Rule
Method of Equal Shares
Method of Equal Shares with Approval Voting Completion
Method of Equal Shares with Increment Completion
Proportional Approval Voting
Eneström–Phragmén
Satisfaction Approval Voting
Sequential Proportional Approval Voting
Phragmén's Sequential Rule
Popularity
max. popularity:
Inclusion
max. inclusion:
Satisfaction Distribution

See All 71 Comments

Explanations

Analysis

Popularity

"Popularity" measures how popular is a set of comments for the participants. It is equal to the total amount of positive votes (thumbs, up or approvals) received by the comments in the selection.

Inclusion

"Inclusion" measures the percentage of participants included in the selection. That is, the percentage of participants who expressed a positive opinion (thumb up, or approval) about at least one of the selected comments.

For instance, an inclusion of 60% means that 60% of the participants feel positively about at least one comment of the selection.

Inclusion can also be expressed in terms of satisfaction: the inclusion is the percentage of participants with non-zero satisfaction.

Satisfaction

The "satisfaction of a participant" measures the number of selected comments that they expressed a positive opinion (thumb up, or approval) about.

For instance, a satisfaction of 3 means that the participant feels positively about 3 of the selected comments.

Selection Methods